Tonight, April 30th, on Live! with Lisa, I spoke on-air by telephone live with two brave college students from Ithaca College about an ugly incident on campus today that made them feel emotionally intimidated as Jews and pro-Israel supporters. Here is the email I received today before the show:
Dear Lisa Wexler,
I wanted to give you a brief update of what is happening at Ithaca College.
On Tuesday evening, the members of the Student Alliance for Israel wrote a letter to the student leaders of Students for a Just Peace expressing our upset with their use of the Palestinian flag on Israel’s Independence Day. We copied that to the school president, Thomas Rochon and the school newspaper, The Ithacan, to inform them about the sentiments we see on campus. SJP sent a very aggressive and manipulative response to our email, in which the same parties were copied. After our returned clarifying response to their email, Beth Harris, a full Politics professor as well as the SJP faculty advisor, wrote an email propagating her stance on the argument to the entirety of the politics department asking for their support. Later that day that email circulated around several academic departments and was then forwarded to students.
In Beth Harris’s actions, she has practiced a highly unethical use of power. She took our argument entirely out of context to gain support over us and push us down. She emailed the President of the Student Alliance for Israel, and used censorship as an intimidation tactic to pressure her concession. I consider that a personal attack a student and a public attack on the students on campus who support Israel.
Then after today’s Student for a Just Peace demonstration on the academic quad simulating Israel’s use of check points, where students dressed and acted as Israeli soldiers holding guns then acted out shooting and beating pregnant women and children, my feelings of personal and public attack have exponentially escalated. The alienation we feel for being Israel supporters while members of the campus community has left us at times in an inconsolable emotional state and reluctant to participate in campus life.
Other Jewish students and Israel supporters have contacted me through email, phone call, and text message explaining their upset and feelings of criminalization by SJP. This is not a safe environment for us. This is not an environment where I and my fellow Israel supporters feel anything but distress, upset, and fear about the climate on campus. The actions of Students for a Just Peace, Beth Harris, and the several professors that came out to support them today are absolutely unconscionable and paralyzing to the Israel-supporting members on campus and the entirety of the Jewish Community.
We ask you please, for your support during this difficult time on campus. Is there anything you can do to help us to continue to support Israel? Any resources you have would be appreciated! Thank you so much in advance for your time!
Sincerely,
Alyia Bettman
Student Alliance for Israel
Ithaca College
MY COMMENTS:
Tonight on my radio show, Live! with Lisa, on 1400 WSTC and 1350 WNLK, also streaming at
www.wstcwnlk.com, Alyia and her friend Molly called in live to the show to express their concerns about this incident. They said they felt intimidated and emotionally extremely upset over what had happened at the school they love. They felt betrayed by this particular professor and by the college administration. The professor patently took sides and escalated this into an ugly incident. The college administration has done nothing. Period. Here are my reflections and responses:
1. Why does a college campus raise a Palestinian flag in the first place? Don’t we live in America? The students told me that no Israeli flag had ever been raised to their knowledge nor had the flag of any other soverign entity. Incidentally, who invented the Palestinian flag? Technically, there is no Palestine yet, right?
2. If I lived in a college quad and saw this, I too would be extremely emotionally upset. It would be like watching Nazis goose-stepping on my front door. It doesn’t mean these students don’t have the right to protest. As a matter of free speech, they do. It doesn’t mean the pro-Palestinians don’t have the right to inflame the conflict, disseminate misinformation, and display propoganda in furtherance of their side of the issue. They do have this right. Nevertheless, it is both sad and outrageous that an international conflict is being brought to the center of an American college campus. This isn’t the UN. And this isn’t about an American issue. It’s about an issue and a conflict occurring thousands of miles away.
3. College in America should be about exploring one another’s differences in an enlightened and peaceful setting, so that friendships can form and other perspectives can be appreciated. I fear that with this militant, no holds barred approach that was started by the pro-Palestinian faction, just the opposite will be achieved. Instead of friends, enemies. Instead of understanding, reflexive adherance to one’s original point of view. Instead of tolerance, bigotry and hatred. If this is what our colleges tolerate, then what will our kids become once they graduate? What will this bode for the future of our American society?
I do not recall the British/IRA conflict reaching American college campuses in this way. Do you?
4. What this really says, and what was so frightening to these girls, is that they discovered that the world around them really hates them. They discovered that while only a handful of students actually participated in these protests, many more silently agree with their sentiment that Israel is the true and sole culprit and cause of the suffering of the Palestinian people. They have discovered that while they thought they lived among friends and professors whom they respected and admired, in fact they live among people who will either participate in purposely wounding their feelings, or who will ignore their feelings altogether, which is in some ways, worse. In short, these girls have had to grow up fast, to acknowledge the realization that the America they thought they knew is changing quickly into an America hostile to Israel, and intolerant of debate. The implications of this incident are sure to sink in; eventually they will result in some Jews leaving this nation altogether, as so many have done in France.
5. I am told there are several organizations that can help- Stand With Us, the David Project and Camera.You can go on line and request their material. There is a DVD from Stand with Us “Hate speech on Campus” dealing with the issue. Also the David Project comes to campuses and teach students on how to speak up for Israel.
6. Professor Beth Harris needs to go before her employers at Ithaca College and answer an inquiry as to her actions on this matter.
7. The pro-Israel supporters at Ithaca College need to counter this with a massive protest of their own.
8. Where is the college administration here? Ducking the issue won’t make it go away.
9. Maybe parents of Jewish kids ought to think twice about sending their kids to Ithaca College.